
The Lodge at St Edward Park
Best for nature-focused stays, wedding and event weekends, and guests who want forest trails and a small‑hotel feel.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Lodge at St Edward Park is an 84-room restored 1931 seminary set inside Saint Edward State Park for travelers who want forest trails, lake access and a quiet retreat. The Edgewater Hotel is an iconic 4-star waterfront hotel on Elliott Bay for travelers who want downtown Seattle sights and an over-water Seattle experience.
Updated · about 15 miles (24 km) apart

Best for nature-focused stays, wedding and event weekends, and guests who want forest trails and a small‑hotel feel.

Best for downtown sightseeing, waterfront views, and guests who want to be steps from the Seattle Waterfront and cruise piers.
When The Lodge at St Edward Park wins: choose the Lodge for a quiet, small-hotel retreat inside a large state park — hiking, lakeshore access, on-site Vita Nova Spa (adult-only), indoor pickleball and a close-to-nature setting.
When The Edgewater Hotel wins: choose the Edgewater for a central downtown location on Elliott Bay, easy walking access to Pike Place Market and Seattle Waterfront attractions, classic over-water rooms and a long-standing Seattle identity.
Bottom line: pick The Lodge at St Edward Park for a restful Pacific Northwest park escape and spa/active‑sport amenities; pick The Edgewater Hotel for a central, recognizable Seattle waterfront base and immediate access to downtown attractions.
| Category | The Lodge at St Edward Park | The Edgewater Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small, historic-architecture retreat inside a state park with quiet, nature-focused programming. | Iconic, larger downtown waterfront hotel with city and water views and an over-water setting. |
| Location | In Saint Edward State Park, Kenmore — forest trails and Lake Washington shoreline nearby. | On Elliott Bay at Pier 67 in downtown Seattle, steps from the Seattle Waterfront and Bell Street Cruise Terminal. |
| Size | 84 guestrooms across five floors. | 223 guestrooms (supplier listing). |
| Who can stay | All ages welcome; spa access restricted to guests 18+. | All ages welcome (children 17 and younger stay free when using existing bedding). |
| Pools & waterfront | No on-site pool or hot tub; direct access to Saint Edward Beach and undeveloped Lake Washington shoreline. | Waterfront / over-water rooms on Elliott Bay; on-site pool/hot tub information not published. |
| Restaurants & bars | Cedar + Elm (signature Pacific Northwest restaurant) plus Father Mulligan's Heritage Bar and The Tonsorium Bar. | One on-site restaurant and a coffee shop/cafe plus bar/lounge; full breakfasts available for a fee. |
| Spa & wellness | Vita Nova Spa (infrared sauna, five treatment rooms; open select days; 18+), 24-hour fitness and indoor pickleball courts. | On-site fitness facilities and concierge services; spa details not published. |
| Known for | Historic seminary building in a 326-acre forest park and event/wedding spaces (Remington Ballroom, Great Lawn). | A hotel built over/adjacent to Elliott Bay with strong downtown proximity (Pike Place Market, cruise terminals). |
| Parking & transport | Free valet parking, electric-charging station, complimentary Sprinter van for local trips (availability based). | Valet parking (surcharge) and limo/town car service available; preferred airport SEA. |
| Wi‑Fi & connectivity | Free in-room Wi‑Fi included for all guests. | |
The Lodge sits inside Saint Edward State Park with forest trails and lake access.
Pick the Lodge for a nature-focused, quieter base and access to hiking and lake activities.
The Edgewater sits right on Elliott Bay at Pier 67 within easy walking distance of downtown Seattle attractions.
Pick the Edgewater for maximum downtown convenience and waterfront city access.
The Lodge offers 84 rooms in an intimate, historic seminary building.
Choose the Lodge for smaller, characterful rooms and a slower pace.
The Edgewater has a wide variety of city-view and over-water room types across a much larger inventory.
Choose the Edgewater for over‑water rooms, variety of room types and direct water views.
The Lodge centers on Pacific Northwest cuisine at Cedar + Elm and two distinct bars.
Pick the Lodge for regionally focused dining and a multi-venue on-site food & drink program.
The Edgewater offers an on-site restaurant, a coffee shop/cafe and a bar/lounge for waterfront meals and drinks.
Pick the Edgewater for convenient downtown dining with waterfront views and quick access to many city options.
The Lodge does not have an on-site pool, but the park and lakeshore are the primary outdoor draw.
If waterfront swimming or a pool is essential right now, the Lodge does not offer one; its natural shoreline and trails are the alternative.
The Edgewater's signature outdoor draw is its over-water location on Elliott Bay.
Choose the Edgewater for an over-water downtown experience; pool details are not published.
The Lodge focuses on wellness and small‑scale recreation in a park setting.
Pick the Lodge if you want an active, wellness-focused stay with park activities and scheduled spa time.
The Edgewater offers downtown nightlife access and basic fitness options.
Pick the Edgewater for easy access to Seattle nightlife, sightseeing and waterfront excursions.

Direct access to Saint Edward State Park trails, Lake Washington shoreline and a park setting.

Steps from the Seattle Waterfront, Pike Place Market and cruise terminals.

Historic Remington Ballroom, Great Lawn and multiple indoor/outdoor event spaces for intimate celebrations.

Over-water rooms on Elliott Bay and immediate access to downtown Seattle attractions.
Both welcome children of all ages. The Lodge offers park trails, playground access nearby and family-friendly outdoor activities; the Edgewater places families within walking distance of downtown attractions like the aquarium and Pike Place Market.
The Lodge at St Edward Park does not have an on-site pool or hot tub; guests use park beaches or nearby public pools. The Edgewater supplier listing does not publish on-site pool/hot tub information.
The Edgewater is much more convenient for downtown sightseeing—it's on the waterfront near Pike Place Market and cruise piers. The Lodge is better if you prefer a park/lake base and don't mind a drive into downtown.
The Lodge has Vita Nova Spa (open select days; 18+). The Edgewater's supplier listing does not publish spa details.
Explore how The Lodge at St Edward Park stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·