
The Lodge at St Edward Park
Best for outdoor and family activities — direct access to Saint Edward State Park trails, lakeshore, complimentary bikes and indoor pickleball.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Lodge at St Edward Park is an 84-room historic seminary hotel set inside Saint Edward State Park, best for travelers who want a park-set, family-friendly Northwest retreat. Four Seasons Hotel Seattle is a 147-room flagship 5-star hotel on the downtown waterfront, aimed at travelers who want central Seattle access, full-service luxury, and city/harbor views.
Updated · about 15 miles apart

Best for outdoor and family activities — direct access to Saint Edward State Park trails, lakeshore, complimentary bikes and indoor pickleball.

Best for downtown convenience and five-star service — steps from Pike Place Market and the Seattle waterfront with full spa, pool and meeting facilities.
When The Lodge at St Edward Park wins: Choose the Lodge if you want a quieter, park-centered stay, historic architecture, easy trail and lakeshore access, complimentary bikes and family-friendly outdoor activities. It suits guests who prioritize nature, small scale and regional dining.
When Four Seasons Hotel Seattle wins: Pick Four Seasons for a central location near Pike Place Market and the waterfront, larger full-service spa, outdoor pool and hot tub, on-site meeting/event capacity, and a classic urban luxury experience with limousine/town car options.
Bottom line: Both are luxury options but serve different needs — The Lodge is a boutique park retreat with strong outdoor programming and historic character, while Four Seasons is a downtown 5-star with waterfront views, more rooms and full-service hotel facilities. Your choice depends on whether you prefer a nature-first escape or central-city luxury.
| Category | The Lodge at St Edward Park | Four Seasons Hotel Seattle |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic seminary remade as a boutique park lodge with regional character | Flagship 5-star downtown hotel focused on waterfront views and full-service luxury |
| Location | Set inside 326-acre Saint Edward State Park near Lake Washington (Kenmore) | Central Seattle on the waterfront, steps from Pike Place Market and Benaroya Hall |
| Size (rooms) | 84 guestrooms | 147 guestrooms |
| Age / building | Restored 1931 seminary building (landmark) | Modern flagship city hotel (opened as Four Seasons property) |
| Pools & water access | No on-site pool or hot tub; park trails lead to undeveloped Lake Washington shoreline | Outdoor pool, hot tub and sauna on property |
| Restaurants & bars | Cedar + Elm (signature), Father Mulligan's Heritage Bar, The Tonsorium Bar | One on-site restaurant and one bar/lounge; 24-hour room service available |
| Spa & wellness | Vita Nova Spa (reservations required; 5 treatment rooms, infrared sauna), 24-hour fitness, indoor pickleball | Full-service spa with massages, body treatments and facials; 24-hour fitness |
| Meeting & event space | 9,000+ sq ft of indoor/outdoor event space, Remington Ballroom and multiple venues for weddings | Approximately 10,500 sq ft conference space with 6 meeting rooms and banquet facilities |
| Family & pets | All ages welcome; playground and park activities nearby; dogs allowed in designated rooms (fee applies) | Family-friendly property; children 17 and younger stay free with existing bedding; pet policy: Not published |
| Transport & parking | Free valet parking, electric car charging, complimentary Sprinter van within 10 miles (availability-based) | Valet parking (surcharge), limo/town car service available, close to cruise terminal and city transit |
| Wi‑Fi | Free in-room Wi‑Fi | |
The Lodge sits inside Saint Edward State Park, with trails and undeveloped Lake Washington shoreline steps away.
Choose The Lodge for nature, lakeside walks and a more rural park setting while staying within reach of the Eastside wine country.
Four Seasons is a central waterfront hotel in downtown Seattle, a short walk from Pike Place Market and major cultural sites.
Pick Four Seasons for walking access to downtown Seattle attractions and convenient city-side logistics.
The Lodge has 84 rooms across five floors in a restored 1931 building with a small number of named room types.
Rooms emphasize historic character and a boutique scale; families with infants should note no cribs/extra beds.
Four Seasons offers a larger inventory of rooms and suites, including Seattle-view and bay-view options.
Four Seasons provides a wider choice of room categories and views, suitable for travelers who want room variety and city or water vistas.
Dining at The Lodge centers on Cedar + Elm and two on-site bars with Pacific Northwest menus.
The Lodge focuses on regional cuisine and relaxed bar settings tied to the park and hotel history.
Four Seasons offers on-site restaurant service and 24-hour room service consistent with full-service luxury hotels.
Four Seasons is convenient for city dining, in-room dining and concierge-driven restaurant planning.
The Lodge does not have an on-site pool but provides extensive park and active options.
Expect outdoor and active options rather than an on-site pool at The Lodge.
Four Seasons has an outdoor pool, hot tub and sauna as part of its recreational offerings.
Four Seasons is the better choice if an on-site pool and traditional hotel leisure facilities matter to you.
Vita Nova Spa and adult-focused treatments sit alongside low-key on-site bars and music nights.
The Lodge offers a quieter, adult-skewed spa experience and localized evening entertainment.
Four Seasons provides a full-service spa, sauna and nearby city nightlife options.
For extensive spa hours, city night activities and concierge-driven evening plans, Four Seasons has the edge.

The Lodge — direct access to Saint Edward State Park trails, complimentary bikes and indoor pickleball courts.

Four Seasons — walking distance to Pike Place Market, waterfront attractions and city theaters.

Four Seasons — on-site outdoor pool, hot tub, sauna and a full-service spa.

The Lodge — restored 1931 seminary building with regional dining and small scale (84 rooms).
The Lodge welcomes children of all ages and offers park-based activities and a playground nearby. Four Seasons is family-friendly too, especially for city sightseeing; check specific room bedding and child policies when booking.
Neither property is all-inclusive. Both offer on-site dining with most meals charged separately; Four Seasons lists a fee for cooked-to-order breakfast, and The Lodge charges for cooked-to-order breakfast as well.
Four Seasons Hotel Seattle has an outdoor pool and a hot tub. The Lodge at St Edward Park does not have an on-site pool or hot tub; Lake Washington shoreline and a seasonal park pool are nearby.
Both properties have spas. The Lodge's Vita Nova Spa has five treatment rooms and an infrared sauna and is reserved for guests 18 and older; Four Seasons operates a full-service spa with a broader slate of treatments and regular reservations.
Explore how The Lodge at St Edward Park stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·